In a March 2018 investigation report, the BC Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner found that landlords generally collect too much personal information and that proof of income should be collected only when other verification is inadequate.
| Rule | What it says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Federal (PIPEDA) | Landlords may only ask for information that is necessary; the OPC recommends organisations not request SIN numbers | OPC |
| Ontario | Income info only alongside credit references, rental history and credit checks; no rent-to-income ratio such as a 30% cut-off rule | OHRC |
| Quebec | Social condition (including income) is a protected ground; refusing to rent because someone is jobless violates the Charter | CDPDJ |
| British Columbia | T4 is appropriate only when other verification is inadequate; acting privacy commissioner called an unredacted T4 “not appropriate” | BC OIPC, CBC News |
| Alberta | Landlords must collect only necessary information; source of income is a protected ground | CPLEA |
What is on a T4 slip and why does it matter?
A T4 slip is a Statement of Remuneration Paid, issued by employers after each calendar year summarising employment income and deductions (CRA). The main privacy concern is Box 12, which contains your Social Insurance Number (CRA). The slip also shows total employment income (Box 14), income tax deducted (Box 22), CPP/QPP contributions, EI premiums, and your employer’s name and address.
The OPC has recommended that private-sector organisations not request SIN numbers. A landlord who collects your SIN takes on data they do not need for income verification.
Can you refuse to provide a T4?
Under PIPEDA, a landlord must identify the purpose of collection, obtain consent before collecting, and may only use information for the stated purpose. Privacy law in every province follows a similar necessity principle.
Under PIPEDA, landlords may only collect information that is necessary, so a tenant can offer other documents that verify income.
BC’s acting privacy commissioner Drew McArthur put it directly: “We’ve seen cases … where landlords are looking to confirm employment and confirm income for ability to pay, but they’re asking for unredacted copies of an employee’s T4 slip. That’s not appropriate. A landlord doesn’t need all that information” (CBC News).
What can you offer instead of a T4?
Several documents verify income without exposing your SIN.
- Recent pay stubs showing your employer and gross pay
- An employment letter confirming your position and salary
- A CRA Notice of Assessment
- Bank statements showing regular deposits
The Province of British Columbia’s guidance tells landlords they may collect “verifiable income and employment” and “references” (Province of BC). Ontario defines “income information” as “information about the amount, source and steadiness of a potential tenant’s income” (OHRC). Neither requires a T4 specifically.
How do the rules differ by province?
Ontario. Under Ontario Regulation 290/98, landlords may request income information from a prospective tenant only if the landlord also requests credit references, rental history and credit checks. They must consider income together with all the other information obtained. It is illegal to apply a rent-to-income ratio such as a 30% cut-off rule (OHRC). Income information can only be considered on its own when no other information is made available (OHRC).
Quebec. The Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, s. 10 prohibits discrimination based on “social condition,” which includes occupation, income, education and homelessness. Refusing to rent just because someone is jobless or receives social assistance violates the Charter (Éducaloi).
British Columbia. The BC OIPC Investigation Report P18-01 found that proof of income falls in the “sometimes” category. If the information already available is insufficient to establish an applicant’s history of rent payment, a landlord may request proof of income or employment. An unredacted T4 goes beyond what is appropriate.
Alberta. Under PIPA, landlords must collect only necessary information, tell the applicant why they need it, get clear consent before using it, and store it safely and securely. Source of income is a protected ground under Alberta human-rights law.
Must the landlord destroy your documents afterward?
Under PIPEDA, a landlord may only use personal information for the stated purpose and must identify the reasons for collecting it before or when they collect it. Quebec’s Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, as updated by Law 25, requires destruction or anonymisation once the purpose is achieved (Immomulti). Alberta similarly requires landlords to store information safely and securely (CPLEA).





