On November 25, 2025, HUD withdrew three earlier documents, including its 2016 guidance (Nelson Mullins). That guidance had warned that “arbitrary and overbroad criminal history-related bans are likely to lack a legally sufficient justification” (HUD OGC Guidance, 2016). The change gives landlords more screening discretion.
What does the Fair Housing Act say about criminal record screening?
A policy that screens on criminal history can still violate the Fair Housing Act if it has a disparate impact on a protected class. The statute and court precedent still apply to policies with a discriminatory effect, even after HUD withdrew its 2016 interpretive guidance (Moks Law).
What did HUD change about criminal screening guidance in 2025?
HUD rescinded three earlier documents on November 25, 2025, stating that the prior guidance caused “confusion” and a “chilling effect” on lawful screening (Nelson Mullins). HUD now says safety is paramount and that housing providers have discretion to screen based on “a history of criminal activity which would adversely affect the health, safety, and peaceful enjoyment of the property” (Wallace Law).
| Before (2016 guidance) | After (November 2025) |
|---|---|
| Blanket bans “likely to lack a legally sufficient justification” | Guidance withdrawn; landlords have broader discretion |
| Arrests alone “not a reliable basis” for denial | Guidance withdrawn |
| Individualized assessment expected for convictions | Guidance withdrawn |
| Fair Housing Act disparate impact doctrine applies | Fair Housing Act disparate impact doctrine still applies |
The 2016 guidance had required that a screening policy “must be applied on a case-by-case basis considering the nature and severity of the conviction, what the individual has done since conviction, and how long ago the conviction took place” (HUD OGC Guidance, 2016). That requirement is no longer federal policy.
What is the difference between arrest records and conviction records in screening?
HUD’s 2016 guidance, since withdrawn, said “an arrest is not a reliable basis upon which to assess the potential risk to residents or property” (HUD OGC Guidance, 2016). The FCRA treats arrest records and conviction records differently.
Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, “records of arrest” cannot appear on a consumer report if they are older than 7 years (15 USC 1681c(a)(2)). Criminal convictions, by contrast, can be reported indefinitely. The statute excludes “records of convictions of crimes” from the 7-year cap on adverse information (15 USC 1681c(a)(5)).
Some states go further. California’s FEHA regulations prohibit considering “an arrest that never led to a conviction” (2 CCR § 12269(a)(1)).
Which states and cities restrict criminal record screening for housing?
Several jurisdictions have Fair Chance Housing ordinances that go beyond federal law. Among them:
- California prohibits blanket criminal record bans under FEHA regulations. A landlord must screen only for “directly-related convictions” (2 CCR § 12266) and may not use “a blanket ban or categorical exclusion practice that takes adverse action against all individuals with a criminal record” (2 CCR § 12269(a)(5)).
- Seattle bars most conviction-based denials outright (LeaseRunner).
- New York City (Local Law 24) requires a conditional offer before running a criminal check (LeaseRunner).
- New Jersey, Cook County (IL), Portland (OR), San Francisco, Oakland, and D.C. also restrict criminal record screening for housing (LeaseRunner).
What must a landlord do after denying based on a criminal record?
The FCRA requires an adverse action notice. When information in a consumer report leads a landlord to deny housing, the landlord must tell the applicant of their right to see the report and dispute inaccuracies (FTC).





