Under 26 U.S.C. §6103(a), “returns and return information shall be confidential” and the IRS cannot disclose them without taxpayer authorization, but nothing stops an applicant from handing over their own.

When should a landlord request tax returns?

Tax returns are most useful when an applicant has no traditional pay stubs. Self-employed applicants, freelancers and people with variable income often cannot produce a single employer’s pay stub or W-2. For these applicants, landlords commonly request one to two years of tax returns plus three to six months of bank statements.

For salaried applicants with steady pay stubs or W-2s, a tax return adds less information and exposes more personal data than necessary. A full Form 1040 with all schedules contains the applicant’s Social Security number, bank account details, medical-expense deductions and business income breakdowns (SafeRedact).

Applicant type Strongest income document When to add a tax return
Salaried, single employer Recent pay stubs or W-2 Rarely needed
Self-employed or freelance Tax return (1-2 years) Standard practice
Multiple income sources W-2s and 1099s Helps confirm total income
Voucher or benefit recipient Award or benefit letter Only if other income also needs verification

What are the Fair Housing rules for requesting income documents?

Every screening criterion must be applied uniformly. The Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful “[t]o discriminate against any person in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling … because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin.” The HUD/DOJ Joint Statement confirms that “housing providers may adopt and apply uniform, objective and nondiscriminatory criteria designed to evaluate a prospective tenant’s credit and financial ability to pay rent.”

That means a landlord who asks one applicant for a tax return must ask every applicant who meets the same conditions. Requiring tax returns only from applicants of a particular race or national origin violates federal law.

Source-of-income protections add another layer. As of 2026, 24 states plus the District of Columbia and more than 130 cities and counties prohibit landlords from refusing to rent solely because an applicant’s income comes from a Housing Choice Voucher, Social Security, VA benefits, child support or other lawful sources (Housing Solutions Lab). In those jurisdictions, a landlord cannot reject a voucher holder for the income source itself but can still require the applicant to meet other screening criteria such as credit and rental history.

Can an applicant redact their tax return before sharing it?

Yes. A landlord typically needs adjusted gross income, filing status and the applicant’s name. An applicant can redact their full Social Security number to the last four digits, black out bank account and routing numbers, and remove sensitive schedules like medical expenses (SafeRedact).

There is good reason to do so. Congress amended IRC 6103(c) so that recipients of return information disclosed with taxpayer consent are “subject to penalties for any unauthorized access, other use, or redisclosure without the taxpayer’s express permission or request.” Redacting unnecessary details before the return leaves the applicant’s hands reduces the risk of misuse.

The IRS operates an Income Verification Express Service (IVES) that lets “mortgage lenders, banks, credit unions and others” verify income via tax transcripts with taxpayer consent (IRS IVES). Landlords are not listed as enrolled IVES participants, so most landlords rely on the applicant’s own copy rather than an IRS transcript.

What alternatives can a landlord accept instead of tax returns?

Several documents verify income without exposing the detail a full tax return contains (Innago):

  • Pay stubs
  • W-2 forms (prior year)
  • 1099 forms (for contract or freelance income)
  • Bank statements (three to six months)
  • Employer income verification letter
  • Social Security or pension benefit statements
  • Profit-and-loss statements (self-employed applicants)
  • Court-ordered award letters

If a landlord takes adverse action based on information in a consumer report, such as denying the application, the FTC requires an adverse action notice to the applicant. Tax returns handed over directly by an applicant are not consumer reports under the FCRA, but any credit report or background check pulled through a screening company is (FTC).

A landlord who does not need the full detail of a tax return can ask for the documents above first and reserve the tax-return request for applicants whose income cannot be verified another way.