In a release dated November 15, 2022, the CFPB said “a reported 68% of renters pay application fees when applying for rental housing” (CFPB).

What is a tenant background and credit check?

It is a tenant screening report, and the CFPB says “landlords use tenant screening reports to help make decisions on possible tenants” (CFPB). A credit report is only one part of it: “a statement that has information about your credit activity and current credit situation” (CFPB). A background check adds the rest, such as criminal, eviction and rental history.

Running both in one report is normal, because the CFPB lists credit reports next to the other checks in a single screening report. Accuracy is a real problem, though. The CFPB reviewed “more than 24,000 complaints” and counted “more than 16,000 complaints about incorrect information on their reports” (CFPB).

What does a tenant screening report include?

Whatever checks your package covers. The CFPB says a report “may consist of any or all of the following” (CFPB):

  • Credit reports.
  • Rental history, including any eviction actions and lawsuits.
  • Employment verification.
  • Criminal history.
  • Sex offender registries.
  • National terrorist watchlist.
  • A risk score or recommendation based on criteria selected by the landlord.

Packages vary by provider. On SmartMove’s pricing page, Basic includes ResidentScore and a criminal background report, Plus adds credit and eviction-related reports, and Premium adds an income insights report and an identity check (SmartMove pricing).

Do you need the applicant’s permission?

You need a permissible purpose, and the FTC says written permission is a way to show it. The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) allows a report for a person with “a legitimate business need for the information” that arises “in connection with a business transaction that is initiated by the consumer” (15 U.S.C. § 1681b).

The consumer’s written instructions are also a permissible purpose under § 1681b(a)(2). The FTC says “landlords may get consumer reports on applicants and tenants who apply to rent housing or renew a lease,” and adds: “You may also get written permission from applicants or tenants to show that you have a permissible purpose” (FTC). Getting signed permission on every application is good practice.

You must also certify to the screening company “that you will use the report only for housing purposes” (FTC).

Getting this wrong costs money. For willful noncompliance, the FCRA allows actual damages or statutory damages “not less than $100 and not more than $1,000” (15 U.S.C. § 1681n). A person who obtains a report under false pretenses or knowingly without a permissible purpose faces actual damages or “$1,000, whichever is greater.”

How do you run a credit check on a tenant?

Set your criteria, get permission, order the report, then decide and keep a record. For the whole process from first inquiry to signed lease, see the tenant screening guide.

  1. Write your criteria and apply them to everyone. Income, credit and rental history standards should be the same for every applicant, and none may turn on a protected class.
  2. Take a complete application. Ordering a report on a half-finished application wastes the fee.
  3. Get signed permission and certify housing use. Certify to the screening company that you will use the report only for housing purposes (FTC).
  4. Pick a service. Common options are TransUnion SmartMove, RentPrep and Zillow Rental Manager, which uses Experian credit reports. Prices are in the next section.
  5. Read the full report yourself. Do not rely only on a score or a pass or fail flag.
  6. Decide and write down why. Note which written criterion the decision rests on.
  7. Send an adverse action notice when it is triggered. That covers a denial, a co-signer requirement, a larger deposit or higher rent based on the report.
  8. Dispose of the report securely. The FTC’s Disposal Rule covers “any business or individual who uses a consumer report for a business purpose,” and its list names landlords (FTC).

A permission line you can adapt for your application:

I authorize [landlord or company name] to obtain a tenant screening report about me from [screening company], which may include my credit report, criminal history, eviction records and rental history, to evaluate my rental application for [address].

Name: ________ Signature: ________ Date: ________

Keep the signed form with the application. The Fair Housing Act bars discrimination because of “race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin” and handicap (42 U.S.C. § 3604), so keep those out of your criteria.

How much does a tenant credit check cost?

“Tenant screening typically costs between $15 and $50 per applicant,” according to iPropertyManagement, last updated July 31, 2026 (iPropertyManagement). The price depends on the package and on who pays.

Provider Package Price
RentPrep Credit report only $29
RentPrep Full background check only (landlord pay only) $29
RentPrep Complete screening package $49
RentPrep Income verification add-on $10
RentPrep Income and employment verification add-on $15
TransUnion SmartMove SmartCheck Basic (ResidentScore, criminal background) $25 plus tax
TransUnion SmartMove SmartCheck Plus (adds credit, eviction related) $42 plus tax
TransUnion SmartMove SmartCheck Premium (adds income insights, identity check) $49 plus tax
Zillow Rental Manager Application with screening reports Free for landlords; $40 paid by the renter

Sources: RentPrep, SmartMove pricing, Zillow Rental Manager. SmartMove’s prices are $25, $42 and $49, plus tax, as listed on SmartMove’s pricing page in November 2026.

Who pays depends on the service and your state. SmartMove lets you “choose who pays (where permitted)” (SmartMove). Zillow says “the application and tenant screening reports are free for landlords,” and the renter’s $40 fee “allows them to apply to your listing and an unlimited number of participating rentals for 30 days” (Zillow Rental Manager).

Zillow’s report “includes an Experian credit report, plus Zillow’s residence history, background check” (Experian). Before you charge applicants anything, check your state’s rules in the next section and in our guide to rental application fees.

Screening is cheap next to an eviction, though the best-known figures are old. SmartMove’s article, updated September 14, 2022 and based on 2013 TransUnion survey data, says total eviction-related expenses for property managers average $3,500 and the process “can take as long as 3-4 weeks” (SmartMove). It says evictions typically cost $2,540 due to vacancy, and turnover costs may amount to $1,750.

What are state limits on screening fees?

Some states cap the fee, tie it to your actual cost, or ban application fees outright. Check your state before you charge anything.

State Rule Source
New York The lesser of actual cost or $20. You must give the applicant a copy of the check and the receipt or invoice before collecting. Waive the fee if the applicant brings a background or credit check from the past 30 days. N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-A
California $68.96 maximum for 2026. No more than your actual out-of-pocket costs. No fee if no unit is available now or within a reasonable period. Berkeley Rent Board, Civ. Code § 1950.6
Virginia $50, exclusive of actual out-of-pocket costs paid to third parties for background, credit or other pre-occupancy checks. $32 for public housing or HUD-regulated units. Va. Code § 55.1-1203
Washington Notify the applicant in writing or by posting before screening. If you screen yourself, the charge may not exceed the customary costs of a screening service in the area. RCW 59.18.257
Oregon No more than your average actual cost of screening (or the customary amount screening companies charge). Only one charge per applicant within any 60-day period. Refund within 30 days in set cases. ORS 90.295
Massachusetts Application fees are not among the charges allowed at or before the start of a tenancy. M.G.L. c. 186, § 15B
Vermont Application fees are banned. 9 V.S.A. § 4456a

New York. The fee covers background and credit checks only if “the cumulative fee or fees for such checks is no more than the actual cost” or twenty dollars, “whichever is less” (§ 238-A). The waiver for a recent report is one reason portable tenant screening reports matter there. More detail is in what landlords can ask tenants in New York.

California. The statute sets a $30 base adjusted with the Consumer Price Index from January 1, 1998 (§ 1950.6), and the Berkeley Rent Board puts the 2026 maximum at $68.96 (Berkeley Rent Board). On the path set out in § 1950.6(c)(2)(A), you consider applications “in the order in which the completed applications were received,” approve “the first applicant who meets the landlord’s established screening criteria,” and refund “within seven days” applicants whose application is not considered. See what landlords can ask tenants in California.

Washington. The notice must cover the types of information you will check, your denial criteria, the screening company’s name and address, and whether you accept a reusable report (RCW 59.18.257). See what landlords can ask tenants in Washington.

Oregon. The 30-day refund applies if the unit is filled before screening, or if no screening was ordered before the applicant withdrew in writing (ORS 90.295).

Massachusetts. At or before a tenancy, a landlord may require only “rent for the first full month of occupancy,” “rent for the last full month of occupancy,” “a security deposit equal to the first month’s rent,” and “the purchase and installation cost for a key and lock” (M.G.L. c. 186, § 15B).

What credit score do landlords look for?

There is no single number. Hemlane’s 2025 data says landlords who set a minimum “often anchor it around 600, because risk drops sharply above that threshold” (Hemlane). The cutoff is a business choice you write into your criteria and apply to everyone.

For context, these are the standard FICO bands (Capital One):

FICO band Score range
Exceptional 800 to 850
Very good 740 to 799
Good 670 to 739
Fair 580 to 669
Poor 300 to 579

“The average FICO® Score in the U.S. declined to 713 in 2025,” Experian says, using its September 2025 data (Experian). That average falls in the good band (670 to 739).

The rest of this section is vendor data. Across applications Hemlane screened from January to September 2025, “the average Resident Score reached 680,” with “most applicants falling between the mid-500s and the mid-700s” (Hemlane). Hemlane also notes that “a 640 score with 4% risk is not much different from a 680 score with 3% risk.”

TransUnion’s ResidentScore is “a rating from 350-850, with 850 being the best possible score” (SmartMove). TransUnion claims it “identifies 15% more evictions,” a figure its footnote ties to 2016 TransUnion research comparing it with a typical credit score in the bottom 20% score range. It also claims it “identifies 19% more skips,” with no year or basis given.

Does a credit check to rent an apartment hurt the applicant’s credit?

Usually not. Zillow says “most apartment credit checks are what’s called a soft inquiry, which means they won’t lower your credit score” (Zillow), and SmartMove says renters get “no impact to their credit score” (SmartMove).

If the pull is a hard inquiry, the effect is small. myFICO says “for most people, one additional credit inquiry will take less than five points off their FICO Scores,” that hard inquiries stay on the report up to two years and affect FICO Scores for a year, and that soft inquiries do not lower FICO Scores (myFICO). Ask your provider which kind of pull it runs, so you can tell applicants.

What does the FCRA require of landlords?

The federal FCRA asks you to have a permissible purpose, certify housing use, send adverse action notices and dispose of reports securely. It also limits how old the negative items in a report can be.

Rule What it means for you Source
Permissible purpose A legitimate business need tied to a transaction the applicant starts, or the applicant’s written instructions § 1681b
Certify use Tell the screening company you will use the report only for housing purposes FTC
Adverse action notice Required after a denial, co-signer requirement, larger deposit or higher rent based on the report § 1681m, CFPB
Secure disposal Burn, pulverize or shred paper; make electronic data unreadable and unrecoverable FTC
Seven-year limit Civil suits, civil judgments and arrest records older than seven years, or the statute of limitations if longer § 1681c(a)(2)
Convictions Excluded from the seven-year limit § 1681c(a)(5)

On disposal, the FTC says “you must securely dispose of the report and any information you gathered from it” (FTC). The Disposal Rule asks for measures “reasonable and appropriate to prevent the unauthorized access to” the information (FTC).

On time limits, the FTC’s renter guide says screening companies “generally cannot report negative information if it’s older than seven years,” that bankruptcies can be reported for 10 years, and that criminal convictions have no time limit (FTC).

What is an adverse action notice and when must you send one?

You send one whenever you take an adverse action based on a screening report, and that is broader than a denial. The CFPB lists “requiring a co-signer on the rental agreement or lease” and “requiring a larger deposit or a higher rent payment than other applicants” (CFPB). The FTC adds “requiring a deposit that would not be required for another applicant” and “charging a higher amount for rent than for another applicant” (FTC).

Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, the notice must include:

  • The name, address and telephone number of the screening company.
  • A statement that the screening company did not make the decision.
  • The applicant’s right to a free copy of the report if requested within 60 days.
  • The applicant’s right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of the information.

The notice can be oral, written or electronic, but the FTC says “while oral adverse action notices are allowed under the FCRA,” “written notices are the best practice” (FTC). If you used a credit score, the FTC says “you must give the applicant or tenant written or electronic notice that includes the credit score.” The statute lists what goes with it: the score, the range under the model, up to four key factors that hurt it, the date it was created and who provided it (§ 1681g(f)(1)).

A notice you can adapt:

Dear [applicant name],

We have [denied your application / approved it on the condition of a co-signer / required a larger deposit / set a higher rent] for [address], based in whole or in part on information in a consumer report from [screening company name], [address], [phone].

[Screening company] did not make this decision. You have the right to a free copy of your report from [screening company] if you request it within 60 days. You have the right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of any information in the report with [screening company].

[If a credit score was used] Your credit score: [score]. Range of possible scores under this model: [range]. Key factors that adversely affected the score: [up to four factors]. Date the score was created: [date]. Provided by: [name].

If the applicant disputes an item, the CFPB says the company “generally has 30 days to investigate your dispute,” but “in some cases they have 45 days” (CFPB). The statute allows an extension “for not more than 15 additional days” when the consumer sends relevant information during the first 30 days (§ 1681i).

What if an applicant has bad credit or no credit?

You can approve with conditions, weigh other evidence, or both. Whatever you choose, apply the same rules to every applicant in the same situation.

  • Ask for a co-signer or guarantor. Requiring one because of the report is itself an adverse action, so send the notice (CFPB).
  • Ask for a larger deposit, where your state allows it. This is also an adverse action. Massachusetts, for example, lists “a security deposit equal to the first month’s rent” among the only charges allowed at the start of a tenancy (M.G.L. c. 186, § 15B).
  • Weigh income. An industry guideline, not a law, says “a tenant’s gross monthly income should be between 2.5 and three times their rent” (LeaseRunner). Check an applicant with the 3x rent calculator.
  • Ask for rent payment history. Credit files rarely show it: the CFPB, citing an industry estimate in 2022, put coverage at “between 1.7% to 2.3% of U.S. renters” (CFPB).

Rent reporting is growing. In a TransUnion survey of 2,006 adults in March 2025, rent payments reported “rose to 13% in 2025, up from 11% in 2024,” and 79% of renters in TransUnion’s 2025 survey table saw their credit scores increase (TransUnion). A thin file can belong to someone who has paid rent on time for years.

How does the Fair Housing Act affect screening?

It bars discrimination because of a protected class. The Fair Housing Act bars discrimination because of “race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin,” and § 3604(f) adds handicap, the statute’s word for disability.

The FTC warns that “a blanket policy of refusing to rent to anyone with a criminal record may violate the Fair Housing Act” (FTC).

HUD’s Office of General Counsel withdrew its April 4, 2016 guidance on the “Application of Fair Housing Act Standards to Use of Criminal Records.” A Federal Register notice of July 17, 2026 says “the withdrawal of the guidance was effective September 25, 2025,” and that withdrawn documents “should not be relied upon as authoritative” (Federal Register).

Can you deny a tenant based on criminal history?

The FCRA limits what a report may show, and the FTC warns about blanket bans. Arrest records older than seven years generally cannot appear in a report, or longer if the governing statute of limitations runs longer (§ 1681c(a)(2)). Convictions are excluded from that limit (§ 1681c(a)(5)).

The bigger risk is how you use the record. A blanket ban on anyone with a criminal record may violate the Fair Housing Act, according to the FTC (FTC). Check your state and local rules too, and put any criminal history criteria in writing before you screen.

How long does a tenant credit check take?

Often minutes. RealPage says “many reports (credit and instant criminal databases) are available within minutes,” while “manual verifications for employment or county-level criminal searches may take 24 to 72 hours” (RealPage).

On Zillow, Experian says “most tenant credit and background checks will be returned within minutes of the renter sending the application,” and manual review can take up to one to two business days (Experian). SmartMove says “most reports delivered same day” (SmartMove).

How do you avoid screening errors and disputes?

Treat every report as a draft until you have checked it. Of the more than 24,000 complaints the CFPB reviewed, more than 16,000 were about incorrect information on screening reports (CFPB).

  • Verify the applicant’s identity before ordering, so the results match the right person.
  • Use a screening company that follows the FCRA.
  • Read the full report, not just the score or recommendation.
  • If an applicant disputes an item, allow the 30 days the company generally has to investigate (CFPB).
  • Keep the application, the signed permission and your written reason together.
  • Dispose of reports securely when you no longer need them (FTC).

How can an AI leasing agent help with screening?

It handles the steps before the report, so you screen applicants who already meet your basic requirements. Nolan answers rental inquiries by phone, text, email and chat, asks questions set by where the unit is, books showings on your calendar and passes renters who want to apply to your team.

The screening decision and the FCRA steps above stay with you.