The CFPB reported in November 2022 that complaints about tenant background checks roughly doubled between January 2019 and September 2022, rising “from 300 a month to nearly 700 a month” (CFPB, Nov 2022), so following each step carefully protects both you and the applicant.

Why does tenant screening matter?

Screening gives you a documented basis for every leasing decision. Without it, you are guessing, and a bad guess is expensive: the average eviction filing rate across tracked sites in 2025 was 8.0%, roughly one case for every 13 renter households (Oak Clause).

Eviction proceedings cost time, legal fees, and lost rent. A consistent screening process will not eliminate that risk, but it reduces it and protects you if a rejected applicant claims discrimination. For a deeper look at credit and background checks, see the background and credit check guide.

What are the steps in the tenant screening process?

Nine steps, from setting criteria to sending a denial notice if needed. Most screenings take 24 to 72 hours once the applicant submits consent (Landlord Studio).

  1. Set written criteria before you advertise the unit. Apply the same standards to every applicant.
  2. Collect a rental application and written consent. The FCRA allows a consumer reporting agency to furnish a report “in accordance with the written instructions of the consumer to whom it relates” (15 U.S.C. § 1681b).
  3. Run a credit report. Look for payment history, outstanding balances, and collections.
  4. Run a criminal background check. Civil records and arrests older than seven years cannot appear on the report under 15 U.S.C. § 1681c. Criminal convictions have no federal time limit.
  5. Run an eviction history search.
  6. Verify income and employment. Ask for pay stubs, tax returns, or an employer letter.
  7. Contact prior landlords. Ask about payment history, lease violations, and notice given before moving out.
  8. Make a decision based on your written criteria.
  9. Send an adverse-action notice if you deny the applicant based on information in a consumer report.

When a renter wants to apply, Nolan tells them your team will follow up and passes it to your team right away, so your request can go out while the renter is still engaged.

What criteria should you use to screen tenants?

Write your criteria before you list the unit and apply them the same way to every applicant. Consistency is both a best practice and a Fair Housing Act requirement.

  • Income-to-rent ratio. The most common industry benchmark is three times the monthly rent (LeaseRunner). This convention traces to the Brooke Amendment, which capped rent in public housing at 25% of income in 1969; Congress raised the cap to 30% in 1981 (HUD PD&R). It is a market convention, not a legal standard.
  • Credit history. Set a minimum score or evaluate the full report for late payments, collections, and debt load.
  • Eviction history. Decide how far back you look and whether a filed case without a judgment counts.
  • Criminal history. See the section below on criminal-history denials.
  • Rental references. Prior landlords, when available.
  • Employment stability. Length of current employment or a history of steady work.

Whatever thresholds you choose, document them. Do not change them between applicants for the same unit.

What does a tenant screening report include?

A standard report covers credit, criminal, and eviction records. A typical package from a service like TransUnion SmartMove includes a “credit report, criminal background check, and 50 state eviction history” with a “Resident Score … built specifically for tenant screening” (RentSpree).

The FCRA limits what can appear. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681c, civil suits, civil judgments, and arrest records older than seven years cannot be reported. Bankruptcies can appear for up to ten years. Criminal convictions have no federal time limit.

One common error is name-only matching. The CFPB found that “one of the most common errors … is the inclusion of negative information that belongs to someone else with the same name” (CFPB, Nov 2022). If an applicant disputes an item, verify it before relying on it.

How much does screening cost and who pays?

Average tenant screening costs run from $15 to $50, and comprehensive packages cost $30 to $75 (iPropertyManagement). Many landlords pass the cost to the applicant as an application fee, but several states cap what you can charge.

State Fee cap or rule Source
New York Fee waived if the applicant provides their own report from the prior 30 days Skybriz
Colorado Must accept tenant-provided reports within 30 days under HB 23-1099 LeaseRunner

Check your state and local rules before setting a fee. For state-specific details, see the application fees guide and individual state pages such as California, New York, and Colorado.

What federal laws apply to tenant screening?

Two federal statutes govern most of the process: the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Fair Housing Act.

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Before you pull a consumer report, you need a permissible purpose. The FCRA allows it when the consumer gives written instructions or when the landlord “otherwise has a legitimate business need for the information … in connection with a business transaction that is initiated by the consumer” (15 U.S.C. § 1681b). In practice, get written consent on your application.

If you deny an applicant based on information in a consumer report, the FCRA requires an adverse-action notice. See the next section for what it must contain.

Fair Housing Act. The Act makes it unlawful to “refuse to sell or rent … or otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any person because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin” (42 U.S.C. § 3604). Disability was added by the 1988 amendments. The Act also prohibits discrimination “in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or rental” on those same bases (42 U.S.C. § 3604(b)). Your screening criteria cannot target or disproportionately exclude people in these protected classes.

What must an adverse-action notice include?

It must contain five elements under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m(a):

  1. Notice of the adverse action (oral, written, or electronic).
  2. The name, address, and telephone number of the consumer reporting agency that supplied the report.
  3. A statement that the agency “did not make the adverse action decision.”
  4. Notice of the consumer’s right to “a free copy of the consumer report” within 60 days.
  5. Notice of the consumer’s right to dispute the accuracy of the report.

Unlike employment screening, housing does not require a separate pre-adverse-action notice. As the FTC has explained, the two-step procedure “is an employment-specific requirement under 15 USC § 1681b(b)(3), not applicable to housing” (FTC, Nov 2016).

How does disparate impact apply to screening criteria?

A screening rule can violate the Fair Housing Act even if it does not mention a protected class. The Supreme Court held that “disparate-impact claims are cognizable under the Fair Housing Act” in Texas Dep’t of Housing v. Inclusive Communities Project, 576 U.S. 519 (2015) (NLIHC).

A blanket policy that screens out a protected group at a higher rate may be challenged unless it serves a substantial, legitimate, nondiscriminatory interest and no less discriminatory alternative exists. This matters most for criminal-history and credit-score criteria. Apply individualized assessments rather than automatic disqualifications where possible.

Can you deny a tenant based on criminal history?

Yes, but blanket bans carry legal risk. HUD’s 2016 Office of General Counsel guidance, which discouraged blanket criminal-history bans, was withdrawn in April and July 2026 (Navigate Housing). The withdrawal removed the guidance document, but the Fair Housing Act’s disparate-impact standard remains in the statute and was upheld by the Supreme Court in 2015.

HUD’s separate March 2024 tenant-background-check resource was not listed in the July 2026 withdrawal notice (Navigate Housing).

Best practices after the withdrawal:

  • Evaluate each applicant individually rather than applying a blanket ban.
  • Check your state and local laws, which may impose their own restrictions on criminal-history screening.

What are portable tenant screening reports?

A portable report is one the applicant orders and can share with multiple landlords. Some states require landlords to accept them.

Colorado requires landlords to accept tenant-provided reports if they are recent, within 30 days, under House Bill 23-1099 (LeaseRunner). Washington allows landlords to accept comprehensive reusable reports under RCW 59.18.257 but does not require it; landlords who accept one cannot charge an additional application fee (Avail). In New York, if an applicant provides their own background and credit check from the prior 30 days, the landlord must waive the application fee entirely (Skybriz).

For a broader look at portable reports, see the portable tenant screening report guide.

Which states add protected classes beyond federal law?

Many states extend protections the Fair Housing Act does not cover. The most common addition is source of income: multiple states, the District of Columbia, and many localities prohibit housing discrimination based on source of income (Local Housing Solutions). If your state has a source-of-income law, you generally cannot reject an applicant solely because they pay with a housing voucher or other assistance.

Other state-added classes vary and may include sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, age, or military status. Check your state’s fair-housing statute and your city or county ordinances. State-specific screening rules are covered in the individual state guides, including California, New York, Texas, Florida, Illinois, and Washington.

How do you set written screening criteria that hold up?

Draft your criteria before you advertise the unit. Written standards protect you if a rejected applicant claims discrimination, because you can show the same rules applied to everyone.

  • State each criterion clearly: minimum credit score, income-to-rent ratio, maximum eviction filings in a set period, and any criminal-history policy with an individualized review step.
  • Do not add or remove criteria for a specific applicant.
  • Do not screen by any protected class under federal, state, or local law.
  • Keep records of every application, the criteria applied, and the outcome.
  • Review your criteria with a local attorney, especially if your jurisdiction has added protections beyond federal law.

Consistent, documented criteria are the strongest defense against a fair-housing complaint and the clearest way to treat every applicant fairly.