In a 2024 peak-season study of 1.5 million leads across 4,300 properties, ResMan found that only 8.7% of prospects who enter the leasing funnel by filling out a guest card end up signing a lease (ResMan).
This guide is about rental leads, not the “Leasing Lead” job title you may see on property management org charts.
Where do leasing leads come from?
According to NAA, 85% of renters use or plan to use rental listing sites like Apartments.com (NAA). And 87% don’t have a specific property in mind when they begin (NAA). Renters typically research an average of 10 properties and seriously consider 3 (NAA).
Each listing site delivers leads differently:
- Zillow sends rental leads via email with a renter profile that includes key renter information, tour request dates and times, and one-click reply functionality (Zillow Help Center).
- Apartments.com supports up to six email lead destinations and one destination phone number per property (Apartments.com Help).
- Facebook Marketplace delivers inquiries through Facebook Messenger (RentSpree).
- Craigslist lets posters choose a temporary craigslist address that relays messages to their actual email address (Propelhq).
- Your property website captures leads through contact forms, chat, and phone calls. In the NMHC/Grace Hill 2024 survey of 172,000+ residents across 4,220 communities, 79% of renters visited a property’s website and 75% visited a listing site (ILS) (NMHC).
Because leads arrive by email, phone, text, chat, and social messaging, you need a system that collects them in one place.
What does the lead-to-lease funnel look like?
The funnel has five stages: inquiry, qualification, tour scheduled, tour completed, and application or lease. Each stage has a typical drop-off.
| Stage | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Lead to tour | ~25% | DoorLoop |
| Tour to application | ~40% | DoorLoop |
| Overall lead to lease (average) | 8.7% | ResMan |
| Overall lead to lease (top performers) | 16.5% | ResMan |
High-performing properties achieve a 16.5% conversion rate, requiring only 6 inquiries per lease (ResMan).
Prospects booking tours are 115% more likely to lease than those that don’t schedule, and those completing tours are 63% more likely to sign a lease (ResMan).
How fast should you respond to a leasing lead?
Within five minutes if you can. A study of 15,000+ leads and 100,000 contact attempts found that responding within 5 minutes versus 30 minutes made a lead approximately 100 times more likely to be reached, and roughly 21 times more likely to be qualified (HBR).
Firms contacting a prospect within an hour were nearly 7 times more likely to have a qualifying conversation than those that contacted the prospect an hour later, and more than 60 times more likely than firms that waited 24 hours or longer (HBR).
The reality falls far short. Among firms that replied within 30 days, the average response time was 42 hours. 37% responded within one hour, 16% in one to 24 hours, 24% took longer than 24 hours, and 23% never responded (HBR).
Renters notice. According to Zillow’s 2018 Consumer Housing Trends Report, 71% of renters expect to hear back from a landlord or property manager within 24 hours (LetHub, citing Zillow 2018 CHTR). Rently reports that 47% of renters would choose a less ideal home if it’s easier to tour (Rently).
What happens to leads that arrive after hours?
Most of your leads arrive when your office is closed. RentEngine found that 56.8% of prospects are contacting properties before work, after work, and on the weekends, and 22.5% of leads arrived on Saturday or Sunday (RentEngine).
If those leads go to voicemail, the damage is measurable. Even 10% of calls going to voicemail results in 28% fewer tours booked (ResMan).
An answering service, AI leasing agent, or automated text-back can close this gap.
How do you qualify a leasing lead?
Ask the basics before you schedule a tour: desired move-in date, budget, number of occupants, pets, and income range. Pre-screening saves tour slots for renters who are a realistic fit and gives your team the context they need before each showing.
A simple script you can adapt:
- Thank the renter for their interest and confirm the unit they asked about.
- Ask their target move-in date.
- Ask if they have pets and how many occupants will live in the unit.
- Confirm their budget range fits the asking rent.
- If everything lines up, offer available tour times.
How do you reduce tour no-shows?
Send personalized reminders. The ResMan study found that personalized tour reminders added 21 completed tours per 100 scheduled, resulting in approximately 7 more leases (ResMan).
Offer more than one way to tour. Leads taking 2+ tour types were 79% more likely to lease than those who only took an agent-guided tour (ResMan). Self-guided tour properties generated 50% more leads and 105% more tours (ResMan).
Steps that help:
- Confirm the appointment by text or email the day before.
- Send a reminder with directions and parking info the morning of the tour.
- Let the renter reschedule easily instead of just not showing up.
- Offer self-guided or video tour options for renters who cannot make a set time.
Can you text leasing leads under TCPA and 10DLC rules?
Under the TCPA, marketing texts sent using an automatic telephone dialing system require prior express written consent: “an agreement, in writing, bearing the signature of the person called that clearly authorizes the seller to deliver … advertisements or telemarketing messages using an automatic telephone dialing system” (47 CFR § 64.1200(f)(9)).
On the carrier side, every text gets blocked or filtered unless the number sending them is A2P 10DLC registered. This requires brand registration and campaign registration through The Campaign Registry (MyFollowUp).
How do you track leasing lead performance?
Track these numbers monthly and compare them against the benchmarks above.
- Lead-to-lease conversion rate. Divide signed leases by total leads. The average is 8.7%; top performers reach 16.5% (ResMan).
- Lead-to-tour rate. A 25% lead-to-tour rate is common for healthy properties (DoorLoop).
- Tour-to-application rate. The benchmark is 40% (DoorLoop).
- Speed to first response. Track the time between a lead arriving and your first reply.
- Source ROI. Compare cost per lead and conversion rate by listing site so you know where to spend.
A leasing CRM or shared inbox that logs every lead, channel, and timestamp makes this tracking possible without spreadsheet work.
How can AI and automation help with leasing leads?
Properties using chatbots generated 23% more leads and scheduled 41% more tours compared to CRM-only properties. Properties with a contact center saw 90% more leads and 125% more tours (ResMan).
Renters expect digital touchpoints throughout the process. Zillow’s 2025 Consumer Housing Trends Report found that 77% of recent renters consider an online application essential, up from 74% in 2024 (Zillow).
Nolan answers leasing calls, emails and chat on your website, texts on your US number once carriers approve it, asks questions set by where the unit is, and works from your listings and your Google Calendar. Where automation fits your workflow:
- Lead qualification. Ask move-in date, budget, and pet questions before a human gets involved.
- Tour scheduling. Let renters pick a time from your live availability.
- Tour reminders. Send confirmations and day-of reminders by text and email.
- Follow-up. Re-engage leads who inquired but did not book a tour.
Start with the step where you lose the most leads. For most properties, that is the first response.






