In April 2024, HUD issued guidance on “how housing providers and companies that offer tenant screening services can screen applicants for rental housing in a nondiscriminatory way” (HUD FHEO Guidance), putting the responsibility squarely on the landlord even when screening is outsourced.
What is a rental application?
A rental application is a form a landlord uses to collect information about a prospective tenant and to get written consent for credit and background checks. It is not a lease. It starts the screening process, and the lease comes only after the landlord approves the applicant.
Every applicant for the same unit should fill out the same form. Using a consistent application protects you under fair housing law and gives you a paper trail if a decision is challenged.
What should a rental application include?
The form should cover seven areas. Keep every section the same for every applicant.
- Personal information. Full legal name, date of birth, Social Security number, government-issued ID, phone number, email.
- Rental history. Current and previous addresses, landlord names and phone numbers, dates of tenancy, reason for leaving.
- Employment and income. Employer name, job title, length of employment, gross monthly income.
- References. Personal or professional contacts who are not current or former landlords.
- Pets and vehicles. Type, breed, weight for pets; make, model, license plate for vehicles.
- Property details. The address and unit the applicant is applying for, desired move-in date, number of occupants.
- Consent and signatures. Written authorization to run credit, criminal and eviction checks. Date and signature.
Collect supporting documents at the same time: two recent pay stubs, a government-issued photo ID, and the most recent bank statement. These let you verify what the applicant writes on the form.
How do you set screening criteria?
Write your criteria before you list the unit and apply them the same way to every applicant. Deciding criteria after you see who applied invites fair housing complaints.
Common criteria include a minimum income, a minimum credit score, no recent evictions and verifiable rental history. Most landlords require gross monthly income of at least 3 times the monthly rent (Bay Management Group). That is an industry standard, not a federal requirement, and you can set a different threshold if you apply it consistently.
HUD’s April 2024 guidance warns that overbroad screening is a problem: “if a screening policy is overbroad (i.e., it screens out unproblematic applicants), a more targeted screening policy could be a less discriminatory alternative” (Fair Housing Project NC). Review your criteria once a year and remove any rule that screens out applicants without reducing your actual risk.
How much can you charge for a rental application fee?
It depends on your state. Some states ban fees outright, some cap them at a dollar amount, and some limit the fee to your actual screening cost. Where no state law applies, landlords typically charge between $30 and $75 per applicant (Avail).
| State | Rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Massachusetts | Banned. A landlord may not require payment for anything except first month, last month, security deposit and locks. | MassLandlords |
| Vermont | Banned. “A landlord or a landlord’s agent shall not charge an application fee.” | 9 V.S.A. § 4456a |
| New York | Capped at $20 or actual cost, whichever is less. Must waive if the applicant provides their own report within 30 days. | RPL § 238-a |
| New Jersey | Capped at $50 (effective May 1, 2026). Includes all associated screening and administrative costs. Adjusted annually for inflation. | NJ Attorney General |
| California | Capped at actual cost or a CPI-adjusted ceiling (base $30 plus cumulative CPI), whichever is less. | RentSpree |
| Colorado | Limited to actual or average processing cost. Must provide a disclosure or itemized receipt. Refund unused portion. Treble damages for violations. | HB 19-1106 |
| Minnesota | Must not exceed cost of screening. Must disclose the screening service used and the criteria. Refund unused portion. | Madgett Law |
| Washington | Landlord may charge only “the costs incurred in obtaining a tenant screening report.” Must provide a receipt and refund excess. | Azibo |
Check your state’s current statute before you set a fee. If your state limits the fee to actual cost, keep receipts from your screening provider so you can show what you paid.
What can’t you ask on a rental application?
The Fair Housing Act, 42 USC § 3604, prohibits discrimination based on “race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, handicap” in the sale or rental of housing. Section 3604(a) makes it unlawful to refuse to rent or make housing unavailable based on any of those classes, and section 3604(b) bars discrimination “in the terms, conditions, or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling.”
In practice, that means your application should not ask about:
- Race, ethnicity or national origin.
- Religion.
- Sex.
- Whether the applicant has children or plans to.
- Handicap.
Many states and cities add protected classes beyond the federal list, such as source of income, marital status, age or immigration status. Check your local law. If a question does not help you evaluate whether the applicant can pay rent and care for the unit, leave it off the form.
How do you screen a rental applicant?
Start with the applicant’s written consent, then follow these steps.
- Run a credit report. Look at the score, outstanding debts, collections and payment history. You need a permissible purpose under the FCRA to pull the report.
- Run a criminal background check. Apply your written criteria. HUD’s 2024 guidance recommends giving applicants a chance to respond to negative information before you decide (Virginia REALTORS).
- Run an eviction history check. Look for filings, judgments and outcomes.
- Verify income. Compare pay stubs to bank deposit history. Ask for two recent stubs and the most recent bank statement.
- Call previous landlords. Confirm dates of tenancy, rent amount, whether rent was paid on time and whether the tenant left the unit in good condition.
- Check references. A brief call to one or two references can flag concerns the paper trail misses.
Housing providers remain liable for screening decisions even when they outsource screening to a third-party tool or AI system (Fair Housing Project NC). If you use a screening service, understand its criteria and make sure they match yours.
How do you spot application fraud?
Fake pay stubs and fabricated landlord references are the most common problems. Look for these red flags:
- Rounded numbers on pay stubs. Real payroll software calculates taxes to the cent. Net pay that ends in .00 every period is unusual.
- Identical net pay across periods. Hours, overtime and deductions vary. Two stubs with the same net pay down to the cent deserve a closer look.
- Mismatched fonts or formatting. Templates downloaded online often mix font sizes or use inconsistent spacing.
- Missing employer identification number (EIN). A legitimate pay stub includes the employer’s EIN.
- Unverifiable landlord references. If the “landlord” phone number does not match public records for the property owner, call the number listed on the county assessor’s site instead.
Cross-reference pay stubs with bank statements. The deposit amounts and dates should match. If they do not, ask the applicant to explain the discrepancy before you make a decision.
How do you approve or deny an applicant?
Apply your written criteria to the information you collected. Document the reason for every decision, whether you approve or deny.
If you deny an applicant based in whole or in part on information in a consumer report, 15 USC § 1681m requires you to send an adverse action notice. The notice must include:
- The name, address and telephone number of the consumer reporting agency that provided the report.
- A statement that “the consumer reporting agency did not make the decision to take the adverse action.”
- The applicant’s right to obtain a free copy of the report within 60 days.
- The applicant’s right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of the report.
HUD also recommends “providing applicants an opportunity to address any negative information that disqualifies them” before you finalize the decision (Virginia REALTORS). An individualized review takes a few extra minutes but reduces both legal risk and the chance of screening out a good tenant by mistake.
Do you need a lead paint disclosure?
Yes, if the unit was built before 1978. Federal law requires every lessor of pre-1978 housing to disclose known lead-based paint and lead-based paint hazards before the renter signs a lease (EPA).
You must:
- Provide the EPA pamphlet on lead hazards.
- Disclose any known lead-based paint or hazards and provide any available records or reports.
- Attach a lead warning statement to the lease.
- Keep a signed copy of the disclosure for three years after the lease begins.
Hand the pamphlet and disclosure to the applicant with the application or before the lease signing. Doing it early gives the applicant time to read it and ask questions.
How long should you keep rental applications?
Most sources recommend keeping applications for three to seven years (Avail). If you provided a lead paint disclosure, federal law requires you to retain the signed disclosure for at least three years (EPA).
Store applications securely. They contain Social Security numbers, income details and other sensitive information. If you keep paper copies, lock them. If you keep digital copies, restrict access to people who need it.
Check your state’s record-retention rules. Some states set their own minimums for landlord-tenant records.
How can you speed up the rental application process?
Processing a rental application typically takes 24 to 72 hours (Avail). Three things slow it down: waiting for the applicant to submit documents, waiting for screening reports, and chasing previous landlords by phone.
Digital applications collect everything in one step. Automated screening services return credit, criminal and eviction reports in minutes instead of days. Consistent, written criteria mean you spend less time deliberating and more time filling units.
When a renter wants to apply, Nolan tells them your team will follow up and passes it to your team, with every qualified lead in a single inbox, so nothing sits unseen.
Whatever tools you use, the process stays the same: collect the application, screen against your written criteria, document the decision, and send the required notices. Faster does not mean less careful.





